I'm not even going to try to offer any constructive criticism to help you improve on this, as this, in my opinion, needs very, VERY little improvement.
The length itself is an amazing feat, and I can tell you're very dedicated to your work. I've actually followed quite a few of your animations, and I'm always impressed with them. Excellent story in this one, too. :)
You have a real gift, I'm telling you that right now. I love this piece. The audio sync problem that only became evident near the end didn't alter my opinion on it at all, I was so wrapped up in the story unfolding before me.
Beautifully, beautifully done. :)
Very good, indeed.
I am atheist, and I approve of this video.
Seriously, though, you have talent. Not many people realize it, but even with great music and art, it still takes an extra something to draw out emotion. You definitely have that something here. I'll admit, I felt a little bummed about the Christianity point working its way in at the end there, but I quickly got over that, and still appreciated the message that you were trying to get across.
And so, I give you a 9/10 and 4/5. And no, you didn't lose points because of the christianity thing, but because of little nitpicks in the animation that could have been polished. Then again, not everyone is a professional animator.
It was very good and uplifting, I would definitely watch this again. :)
That's some imagination you got there.
Well, I'll be damned. That was probably one of the most enjoyable flashes I've seen in a long time! You, sir, are VERY creative. The animation was fluid and smooth, the graphics clean, and well, hell, it's just an all-around awesome flash! Sorry I don't have anything to say in the way of constructive criticism, but that's only because I honestly can't find anything to criticize on. Plus, the flash executes the moral from the quote at the ending flawlessly. :)
Top-notch work, man. Keep it up! ^_^
Oooohh yeah, baby!!
That was sweet! My favorite part was the sniper. As James Carter would say(RH, RH2)," Hell no!" Awesome!
I absolutely love this piece. The fact that it shows so much emotion even though it's just one instrument is really phenomenal. It's incredibly beautiful and deeply moving. It's actually inspired me to make a new song, which I hope to have done soon. :)
thanks superchao. Let me know when u finish it.
This is the kind of music I'd be able to put on repeat while working on various projects, and it'd keep me in a good mood all day. Really nice, relaxing, and calm.
While others are complaining about the slow start, I actually like it. The only thing I'd say is maybe add a bit more variety in the drums, but other than that, it's a very solid song. Excellent work. :)
This is proof that "Carol of the Bells" is the only epic-sounding Christmas song ever conceived. :D
(This is actually the only Christmas song I like, the others just make me want to hit someone, lol.)
Anyway, on to your take. This is a really epic-sounding take on "Carol of the Bells", and I'm loving it. Wonderfully written, and the dynamics are wonderful to listen to.
You also reminded me about a part I forgot to put into my own cover within this piece, lol.
Either way, I love this song, and I love your version of it. Excellent job. :)
Haha! I hear you there! I have never wanted to punch a cartoon character in the face until I heard Betty Boop sing Santa Baby.
You should hear Celtic Woman's version of this song. It's almost too good....... :)
But you're too kind! Thanks for the review and I can't wait to hear your future pieces!
newgrounds.com — Your #1 online entertainment & artist community! All your base are belong to us.